In the last few days I’ve been reading articles about antidepressant use in children and possible negative effect that they can have, specifically suicide. I find this somewhat amusing because this isn’t new information. I took a psych class a few years ago and in it our prof told us about a strange ‘side-effect’ that is possible for almost all anti-depressant drugs. For anyone who is already suicidal, they may be so depressed that they can’t motivate themself to take action and kill themself. This sounds really awful, but that’s basically the case. Once they start medication, the effects are somewhat gradual. You don’t immediately feel 100% better, it takes time. What happens with these individuals is that they start feeling better. They feel just better enough to kill themself. It’s pretty tragic. Studies have shown this for awhile. The best thing to do is closely monitor a suicidal patient for the first few weeks or months of treatment.
The reason this is coming up recently is that while the risk of this happening is relatively low (less than 3%), more and more children are taking anti-depressants now (which are proven to be much less effecting for treating children, but are prescribed very frequently). More and more parents are having children attempt or commit suicide soon after starting new medication. This stemmed new research (most anti-depressants were never fully tested for use in adolescents so not much was known about the specific side-effects they would have), and, as one would expect, children were as likely to have suicidal tendencies as adults, while beginning new anti-depressant medication.
After these new studies were performed, government health advisers stated that anti-depressant drugs should have large, easy to read labels stating the risks of increased suicidal behavior, both for adults and children. Up until this point no such label has been required for anti-depressants.
Doctors fear that these new labels will prevent patients and parents of patients from wanting to use these medications. While there is a chance of suicide, the period of risk may be as short as 9 days. Over time, the use of both therapy and medication combined reduce these risks more than therapy alone.
Personally I think that the labels are important, but more important is communication between doctor and patient or doctor and parents. The risk of suicide can be reduced if the patient is monitored for the first two weeks of treatment. If parents or patients only see a label that says “This product increases risk of suicidal behavior” they may not read the fine print (or there may be no fine print to read) which states that this is a temporary side effect. Once you are past that period of time, many patients feel much better. Communication between doctors and patients is very important even when the medication has non-deadly side effects. We rely on doctors to prescribe us medication that is does more harm than good. If doctors explained all of the possible side effects (or at least the major side effects) the labels would not be necesary.
I’m no Psychologist, I’m not a doctor. I admit that this is just an opinion. Really, I do think that communication is breaking down in some cases and people are on medication they don’t need to be on or that is not beneficial enough for them to be worth the price. I think I’ll spare everyone from my rant on the downslide of medical care in this country…
Related Articles